PPT Slide
9-10 Most often or always offers a critical analysis of existing posted ideas and introduces a different interpretation to an existing idea. Asks provocative questions or makes insightful, critical, evaluative comments. Contributes new information. Expresses ideas very clearly and coherently.
7-8 Agrees or disagrees with existing discussion and provides some justification/explanation but not a critical analysis. Exhibits some good insights and understanding. Expresses ideas clearly and coherently for the most part.